Urus vs Bentayga vs G 63: The LA Super-SUV Question

Three of the most requested SUVs in Los Angeles use the same basic engine — a 4.0-litre twin-turbo V8 — and produce three completely different cars. The engine is the least interesting thing about this comparison.

A Lamborghini Urus, a Bentley Bentayga and a Mercedes-AMG G 63 will all seat five, all carry luggage, and all make a valet stand up straighter. What separates them is character: one is built to be heard, one is built to be quiet, and one is built to be recognised. Getting that right matters more than any number on the spec sheet.

The numbers, side by side

	Urus	Bentayga	G 63
Per day	$999	$1,299	$1,099
Horsepower	641	542	577
0–60 mph	3.5s	4.4s	4.5s
Top speed	190 mph	180 mph	149 mph
Engine	4.0L twin-turbo V8	4.0L twin-turbo V8	4.0L twin-turbo V8
Drivetrain	AWD	AWD	4WD
Seats	5	5	5
Deposit	$2,000 ($1,500 green)	$2,000	$2,000

Two things in that table are worth pausing on. The Urus is the quickest and the cheapest, which is unusual and is mostly a function of how many Urus there are in Los Angeles. And the G 63 gives away 40 mph of top speed to the other two — not because it lacks power, but because it is still a genuine off-road vehicle underneath, on tyres and a chassis that were never asked to do 190.

Urus: the loud one

The Urus is a Lamborghini that happens to have four doors, and it never lets you forget the first half of that sentence. Cold-start it in a hotel forecourt and everyone within a hundred metres turns around. Put it in its sportiest drive mode and the exhaust does theatre on every downshift. Nothing else at this price arrives with the same volume.

It is also genuinely fast in a way the other two are not. Three and a half seconds to 60 mph in a five-seat SUV is supercar arithmetic, and the chassis backs it up — this is the one of the three you would actually enjoy on a canyon road rather than merely survive — and we have a guide to the roads worth taking it on.

The honest trade-off is that it is the firmest riding and the most conspicuous. In its sharper modes the ride is busy over LA's cracked tarmac, and it sits lowest of the three, so steep driveways in the Hills deserve a slow, angled approach. If your reason for renting is to be noticed, none of that is a downside. If you have a client in the back seat, it might be.

G 63: the iconic one

Nothing else on the road is shaped like a G-Wagon, and that shape is doing most of the work. Flat glass, exposed hinges, indicators standing up on the corners of the bonnet, a spare wheel hanging off the back door. It reads as a G 63 from a block away in the dark, which is something neither of the other two can claim.

Underneath it is still a ladder-frame off-roader, and you feel that. The seating position is upright and commanding, the ride is firmer and busier than the Bentayga's, and there is a mechanical honesty to how it moves that either charms you completely or does not. The side-exit exhaust is loud in a deeper, less exotic register than the Urus — more muscle car than supercar.

Practically, the square body is a gift in Los Angeles parking structures: you can see all four corners, so placing it is easier than its width suggests. The catch is the rear door, which is side-hinged and swings out rather than up. At a tight kerb that door needs room, and it opens towards the pavement rather than away from it.

Bentayga: the quiet one

The Bentayga is the most expensive car here and the one that draws the least attention, which is precisely the point. It is the quietest of the three at 70 mph, the most settled over broken surfaces, and by a distance the best place to sit for three hours of Los Angeles to Santa Barbara. Interior materials are a step above both rivals, and it is the only one of the three where a phone call on speaker is genuinely comfortable at freeway speed.

It is not slow — 4.4 seconds to 60 mph is quick by any sane standard — but it is unhurried about how it delivers that. Where the Urus shouts and the G 63 rumbles, the Bentayga simply compresses the distance in front of it and says nothing.

The trade-off is recognition. Outside of people who know cars, a Bentayga reads as an expensive SUV rather than as a specific event. If the brief is content, arrival or being seen, you are paying $300 a day more than the Urus for less attention. If the brief is a client, a parent or a long drive, that is exactly what you want.

The practical column

• Five seats in all three — this is not a differentiator; luggage and door swing are
• Boot space — Bentayga and Urus take a weekend of bags for four without negotiation; the G 63 is competitive but its side-hinged rear door needs kerb clearance
• Ride comfort — Bentayga, then Urus, then G 63, and the gap between first and last is large
• Ground clearance — the G 63 is the only one you would take up a rough canyon fire road without wincing; the Urus sits lowest
• Parking — the G 63 is easiest to place despite its width, because you can see every corner
• Noise — Urus loudest, G 63 deepest, Bentayga effectively silent

So which one

If the brief is…	Book
Content, a shoot, an arrival people should hear	Urus
Best performance per dollar in the fleet	Urus
Clients, parents, or a drive longer than an hour	Bentayga
Discretion with the badge still doing work	Bentayga
Instant recognition, day or night	G 63
A week of mixed use, including rough roads	G 63

Two adjacent options worth knowing about. If the G 63's shape appeals but the noise and the rate do not, the Mercedes G550 is the same silhouette at $899 a day with 416 hp and a much calmer temperament. And if the Bentayga's brief — quiet, refined, five seats — is really what you are after but you want the rear seat to be the best seat, the Maybach GLS 600 at $1,799 is built around exactly that idea.

Every luxury SUV in the fleet, with live rates →